Media Bias Vividly Illustrated In Headlines About Michelle Williams’s Pro-Abortion Golden Globes Speech

Media Bias Vividly Illustrated In Headlines About Michelle Williams’s Pro-Abortion Golden Globes Speech

From CNN to People to Yahoo to Vanity Fair, at least twelve major outlets used some variation of the word "powerful" in their headlines about the speech.
Emily Jashinsky
By

A pregnant Michelle Williams spent her acceptance speech at the Golden Globes on Sunday making an argument for abortion. (For a thorough dismantling of the speech, read The Federalist’s Joy Pullmann: “No, Michelle Williams, Women Don’t Need To Kill Their Kids To Get Ahead.”) As an experiment, I googled “Michelle Williams powerful,” and filtered the search for the past 24 hours to see how many media outlets cheered her on in the same sympathetic language. The results were absurd.

From CNN to People to Yahoo to Vanity Fair, at least twelve major outlets used some variation of the word “powerful” in their headlines about the speech. Take a look at the list, it’s stunning to see the banners one after another. The visual is a remarkably embarrassing representation of media groupthink. Note most of the publications below (with one or two exceptions) don’t openly claim an ideological bias.

CNN: Read Michelle Williams’ powerful speech about choice

E News: Michelle Williams Delivers Powerful Speech About Women’s Rights at the 2020 Golden Globes

People: Michelle Williams Powerfully Champions ‘a Woman’s Right to Choose’ in Golden Globes Speech

Access Hollywood: Michelle Williams Delivers Powerful Women’s Rights Speech At Golden Globes Amid Pregnancy Reports

Vanity Fair: Michelle Williams Delivers Powerful Golden Globe Speech About Women’s Rights

Us Weekly: Michelle Williams Talks Women’s Rights, Shouts Out Daughter and New Fiance During Powerful Golden Globes Speech

InStyle: Michelle Williams’s Powerful Golden Globes Speech Left People in Tears

Marie Claire: Michelle Williams’ Powerful Golden Globes Speech Urges Women to Vote This Year

Yahoo: Michelle Williams called an ‘icon’ after powerful speech about women’s rights at Golden Globes

OK!: Pregnant Michelle Williams Hints At Past Abortion In Powerful Speech

The Hollywood Reporter: Michelle Williams Delivers Empowering Acceptance Speech on Women’s Rights at Golden Globes

Slate: Michelle Williams’ Surprisingly Personal Speech About Abortion Was the Golden Globes’ Most Powerful Moment

Mashable: Michelle Williams delivers powerful speech at Golden Globes about abortion rights

But there’s more. There were the headlines that called Williams’s speech “passionate,” (Time, ET, Refinery29) “moving,” and “emotional.” Harper’s Bazaar deemed it “rousing.” The Associated Press headline, which was reprinted by several other top outlets, claimed Williams “[spoke] for women’s rights.” NBC News said she “champion[ed] a women’s right to choose.” (As did People.)

Time: Michelle Williams Makes a Passionate Plea for Abortion Rights in Golden Globes Acceptance Speech

ET: Michelle Williams Gives Passionate Pro-Choice Speech During Golden Globes Best Actress in Limited Series Win

Refinery 29: Michelle Williams Celebrates A Woman’s Right To Choose In Passionate Golden Globes Speech

TV Guide: Michelle Williams Gives Moving Pro-Choice Speech at Golden Globes

Uproxx: Michelle Williams Delivered A Moving Speech About Women’s Rights At The Golden Globes

Decider: Michelle Williams Delivered An Emotional, Pro-Choice Speech at the Golden Globes

AP: Williams speaks for women’s rights from Golden Globes stage (republished by Washington Post, US News, Washington Times)

Elle: Michelle Williams Uses Her Golden Globes Acceptance Speech To Defend A Woman’s Right To Choose

NBC News: Michelle Williams champions ‘a woman’s right to choose’ in Golden Globes acceptance speech

Harper’s Bazaar: Michelle Williams Dedicated Her Rousing Golden Globes Speech to the Power of Women’s Choice

Vulture: Michelle Williams Says Thanks for the Globe, But Let’s Talk Women’s Reproductive Rights, People

The Guardian: Why Michelle Williams is the real winner of this year’s Golden Globes

On ABC’s “The View” Monday morning, host Abby Huntsman praised Williams’ speech, dubbing it “lovely” and “moving.” And of course Sunny Hostin chimed in with, “It was a powerful moment.”

The bias is as obvious as the groupthink. Remember, this is only a list of headlines. When I dug into the articles, they largely echoed their headlines’ bias. Further, plenty of bad coverage isn’t even included in this list because it came not in the headlines, but the content.

This is an indictment of the coastal media’s hive mind that should humiliate serious journalists on behalf of their industry. Readers deserve much better coverage than the spate of rote, you-go-girl dreck dozens of outlets magically produced in unison.

There are, of course, only so many words to describe certain circumstances. In this case, “powerful” is only one of them if you come from a particular perspective. Technically, of course, a pro-life person could find the speech “powerful” for different reasons, rendering the descriptor neutral—but then again, that’s exactly why the media uses it. I don’t think anyone serious is naive enough to give them the benefit of the doubt.

What’s particularly important to note is that both news outlets and tabloids landed on the same sympathetic messaging. Those are genres of journalism with two different readerships, so the effect is to reach an enormously broad audience with the very same biased narrative.

This is a memorable and instructive case study in the formation of media narratives. Bias is not just CNN. It’s not even just the news media. It’s the entire machine. And, to borrow a word, it’s powerful.

Emily Jashinsky is culture editor at The Federalist. You can follow her on Twitter @emilyjashinsky .

Copyright © 2020 The Federalist, a wholly independent division of FDRLST Media, All Rights Reserved.