Over the weekend a cadre of neocons seemed to be reading from the same set of talking points about the Iran War. Their basic argument is that the only problem with the war is the way it was conducted, not that it was a bad idea to begin with.
Former Vice President Mike Pence said that current Vice President J.D. Vance is wrong that the war was the primary cause of the GOP midterm wipeout (although in fact it was). The real problem, he said, was that we didn’t go hard enough. “I think part of the reason why voters were turned off was because, after seeing our military respond brilliantly in Operation Epic Fury and in the strike against Iran last year, for inexplicable reasons, we stopped after five weeks,” Pence said during an interview on NBC’s Meet the Press. “We sunk their navy, and we had complete air superiority, took down 15,000 military sites in Iran, then we paused and began to embrace the politics of appeasement.”
Mark Levin said something similar on Fox News, that we just need to “finish them off. And if we don’t have generals who know how to do that, get generals who do.” And by “finish them off,” Levin has in mind things like arming the opposition, presumably the Kurds, and then, “strike them as hard as you can, as fast as you can, in every place that’s gonna hurt them and bring them down, and get it over with.”
This is, as Curt Mills of The American Conservative quipped on X, “Actual Fuhrerbunker stuff.” It is utterly divorced from reality, as anyone who even casually followed the Iran War this year could tell you. Iran isn’t Venezuela. There was never a scenario in which we were going to be able to topple the Iranian regime in a matter of days or weeks simply by aerial bombardment. As we’ve seen, in fact, no amount of aerial bombardment alone will ever topple the regime. Rarely if ever in the history of warfare have airstrikes been enough to win a war. And anyway, we bombed them so thoroughly that by August we were nearly out of precision munitions.
So the question is, what should we have done, exactly? The burden here is on the neocons to give a detailed answer. They’re the ones saying we should’ve gone harder, that the Memorandum of Understanding that Trump signed in June was a mistake, and that if we had just had better generals, or more grit, or more something, we would have won.
But neocons like Pence and Levin never do get too specific about what exactly the Trump administration should have done differently in Iran. Beyond vague platitudes like “arm the opposition” and “hit them harder,” what precisely do they have in mind? They act like President Trump had a “destroy Iran” button he could have pushed at any time to bring down the regime in Tehran and win the war, but for some inexplicable reason he refused to push it.
The stark reality is that, once we had executed airstrikes on tens of thousands of Iranian targets, having depleted our precision munitions and sustaining heavy damage to our military bases in the region, the only thing left to do was to send in U.S. ground forces as part of a full regime change war and eventual occupation. Sure, we could have also armed Kurdish militias, but that too would have required some level of U.S. troops to coordinate and assist the militias, to say nothing of the close air support the Kurds would have needed from American forces.
The other option of course would have been to use a nuclear weapon against Iran — an escalation that would have been so reckless and morally insane it boggles the mind that any serious person would consider it.
Is that what neocons like Pence and Levin have in mind? Maybe, but they never openly call for those things (ground troops or nuclear strikes) because they know the American people are totally opposed to them. So instead they couch their arguments in tough-sounding but ultimately empty platitudes about “finishing the job” and “taking out the regime,” while denouncing the “politics of appeasement.”
(The line about appeasement, by the way, is meant as a shot at Vance, who led the MOU negotiations. Pence went after Vance directly this weekend over that very point. But it’s totally disingenuous because it was Trump, not Vance, who signed the MOU and authorized his administration to open negotiations with Tehran. That Pence and other neocons habitually attack Vance, not Trump, over this tells you everything you need to know about their motives.)
What these people want above all is more war, perpetual war. If that means a ground invasion and regime change with a long occupation, so be it. They would be perfectly happy for us to spend twenty years in Iran, as we did in Afghanistan, and call it a victory — so long as the occupation endured. They would do this, and then denounce you as a traitor and a weakling for complaining about higher gas and grocery prices. Anyone who’s not on board with their new Middle East forever war is an appeaser, they’d say. Or a tool of the left. Or a Putin stooge (that one’s a bonus, it works for both Ukraine and Iran).
The bottom line is that you will never hear the neocons lay out a cogent, realistic plan of action to win the war decisively in Iran. Their plan is always the same: to wage war, forever, on your dime. Everything they’re saying now, about how it isn’t the war that was unpopular but how the war was conducted, is exactly what these people said two decades ago about the Iraq War. It’s a cop-out, and no one should let them get away with it.
The truth they will not admit is that it was a disastrous mistake to launch this war against Iran, and there is no obvious way to achieve anything like “victory,” in part because the Trump administration had no theory of victory going into the war. The president clearly had been persuaded that the regime would collapse in a matter of days, and that the Iran operation would be as clean-cut as the Venezuela operation. When that didn’t happen, the neocons wanted Trump to take the next step of a ground invasion followed by a longterm occupation.
Unfortunately, the best course of action, once we had taken out Iran’s leaders and destroyed its air force and navy, might have been simply to walk away, declare victory, and get out, as I argued in late March. That would not be without problems of its own, but at least it would be an honest assessment of the horrible situation we find ourselves in and not, as Pence and Levin want, a replay of the disastrous neocon misadventures in Iraq and Afghanistan.







