Scott Colom’s victory has been described as the “Mississippi Miracle.” His shocking victory, in which he beat incumbent Sen. Cindy Hyde-Smith and became the first Democrat to hold a Senate seat from the state since 1982, came amidst a blue tsunami in which Democrats reclaimed control of both chambers of Congress.
But what makes Colom’s victory — like so many other Democrat wins on Election night — even more surprising is that Mississippi “flipped … with almost no growth in the Democratic vote,” an analysis from Quantus Insights found.
While Democrats captured races in what were once considered Republican strongholds like Mississippi, Iowa, Texas, and Georgia, they didn’t do it because they managed to convince independent or Republican voters writ large.
Quantus Insights found that “of every 100 Trump 2024 voters, about 63 voted Republican, 4 voted Democratic, and 33 stayed home. Of every 100 Harris voters, about 85 voted Democratic. Very few people switched and about a third of one side sat out.”
In states like Texas, Mississippi, and Iowa, the Democrat turnout was roughly the same (or beat) the Democrat turnout for Kamala Harris in 2024. But Republican turnout paled in comparison to Republican turnout in the 2024 presidential election.
Republicans spent the campaign season warning their voters what would happen if Democrats took power, but the voters stayed home anyway because at the end of the day, voting against something clearly doesn’t drive turnout the way voting for something does.
GOP Agenda Missing in Action
House Republican Conference Chairwoman Lisa McClain gave Fox News Digital a preview of the party’s closing pitch.
“[Democrats] want open borders. They want to defund the police, they want to take more money out of your pocket and give it to somebody else. They believe in bigger government. We believe in people. … So those are the things that we’re really hammering home during this election.”
Republicans were reportedly encouraged to talk about “putting more money back in Americans’ pockets and creating more opportunities to get ahead through hard work, ownership, and economic freedom.”
All of that sounds nice. But what bills were Republicans promising to put on the floor in January? What could a voter expect a Republican Congress to do for him that it hadn’t already done? If the Republican-controlled Congress couldn’t pass something as basic as the SAVE America Act — which would’ve required documentary proof of citizenship to register to vote and photo ID to actually vote — what could a Republican Congress do?
McClain, like most Republicans, could tell you exactly what Democrats wanted to do with a majority but couldn’t specify what concrete action Republicans would take to improve life for Americans and fell back on pointing to the dangers of electing Democrats.
But giving voters legitimate reasons to vote for Republicans does work, just ask Newt Gingrich. Gingrich led Republicans to a historic victory in 1994 not because they simply ran as the opposition to President Bill Clinton and Democrats but because Republicans gave Americans the Contract with America, a list of bills they promised to bring to the floor in the first 100 days. Voters had concrete reasons to vote for Republicans because they knew what that would mean legislatively.
Failure to Mobilize for Early Voting
But even if Republicans successfully convince voters that a Republican is more deserving of a vote than a Democrat, that doesn’t guarantee a Republican victory. For years Democrats have treated mail-in voting as the main event, while Republicans still treat Election Day as the main event.
In states that report party registration on returned ballots, registered Democrats beat Republicans in the early vote by more than 10 percentage points, according to USA Today. An analysis by VoteHub found that Republicans “did not win a single day of early voting” in the states it tracked.
Once a ballot is banked, it can’t be undone. It doesn’t matter if there’s a late October surprise or a last-minute motivational push. While Democrats were locking in a coalition weeks before Election Day, Republicans didn’t really do the same. Elections are decided by who casts ballots and increasingly those ballots are cast before Election Day — and overwhelmingly for Democrats.







