Skip to content
Breaking News Alert By Tapping A Dem As AG, Incoming 'Republican' Governor Crowns Wyoming A Liberal State

Confirming Trump Nominees Like Elliot Gaiser Is Thune’s Top Job Right Now, And He’s Failing It

Thune should press holdouts to resolve their objections, publicly shame those who are blocking said nominees, and keep senators in Washington for as long as required until all Trump’s nominees are confirmed.

Share

With Republicans in control of the Senate until January, Senate Majority Leader John Thune has a narrow window to confirm as many of President Donald Trump’s judicial nominees as possible. That means making his own senators stop their obstruction and keeping the Senate working until they are approved. Yet Thune is seemingly unwilling to force the issue, failing one of his final tests as majority leader.

Trump nominated Elliot Gaiser — currently at the Department of Justice’s Office of Legal Counsel — to serve on the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas. But Sen. John Cornyn, R-Texas, is blocking that nomination, instead demanding that the White House nominate former federal prosecutor Steve Fahey for the seat, Bloomberg reported. Under the committee’s blue-slip practice, Cornyn can hold up the nomination by withholding his approval.

While senators can recommend nominees or scrutinize a president’s choice, with weeks left in the Republican majority, insisting the White House start over risks leaving the seat unfilled altogether. Republicans — least of whom Thune — shouldn’t accept losing an opportunity to confirm Gaiser just because Cornyn perhaps has an axe to grind after losing his primary race thanks in part to Trump’s endorsement of his rival, Ken Paxton.

A Republican senator blocking a Republican president’s nominee is a problem for the Republican majority leader to solve. Thune should be pressing Cornyn to back Gaiser despite any personal objections and then working to get Gaiser a hearing while there is still time. By all appearances, this isn’t happening. But Gaiser isn’t the only nominee whose nomination has been caught in the middle of petty Republican senators who let their hatred of Trump and the MAGA movement preclude them from advancing the party’s interests, with Thune tacitly permitting such holdups.

Sen. Alan Armstrong, R-Okla., pulled back his support for Zach West, who was nominated for the Eastern District of Oklahoma. Armstrong complained that the administration allegedly bypassed the state’s recommendations. Outgoing Sen. Thom Tillis, R-N.C., has also stood by Armstrong, leaving West without the Republican votes needed to advance.

Both Tillis and Cornyn have also opposed Lee Rudofsky’s nomination to the 8th Circuit, resulting in the White House withdrawing Rudofsky’s nomination and instead nominating Arkansas Supreme Court Justice Cody Hiland (who was seemingly recommended by the state’s senators).

Each time Thune failed to wrangle in his colleagues, Americans were failed.

The biggest fight played out just this past summer when Tillis and Cornyn threatened to tank the nomination of Todd Blanche for attorney general after the Department of Justice created an anti-weaponization fund to provide restitution to victims of Biden’s weaponization of the judicial system and lawfare. Only after Blanche agreed to end such funding did Cornyn and Tillis vote him out of committee.

But as The Federalist’s Shawn Fleetwood pointed out earlier this year, Cornyn and Tillis — for all their supposed concerns about weaponization — had no problem confirming “several highly partisan nominees put forward by Democrat presidents — some of whom would go on to abuse their positions to target their political opposition.” Those nominees include Merrick Garland as attorney general; Antony Blinken as secretary of state; Pete Buttigieg as transportation secretary; Janet Yellen as treasury secretary; and Miguel Cardona as education secretary, as Fleetwood pointed out.

Instead of fighting to corral his members, Thune allowed Tillis and Cornyn to hold the seat hostage until Blanche caved, even though Americans voted for Trump and his promises to right the wrongs of the past administration.

But Thune shouldn’t resign himself and pretend like intraparty opposition is an excuse to do nothing. He is the leader for a reason: to lead his caucus toward delivering on an agenda. Securing the votes to advance a Republican priority is literally the purpose of having a Republican majority leader.

Yet Thune has tried to shirk those responsibilities, even trying to scapegoat Democrats as the reason for confirmation delays. After the August 2025 recess, Thune accused Democrats of obstructing Trump’s nominees, insisting the ball was in their court.

But as Senate process expert Rachel Bovard told The Federalist, most pending nominees are “two-hour nominees,” meaning cloture requires just 51 votes — which Republicans still have for the next two months — followed by two hours of debate. Thune has always had the ability to file cloture on nominations and keep the Senate working to confirm them. Thune should press holdouts to resolve their objections, publicly shame those who are blocking said nominees, and keep senators in Washington for as long as required until all Trump’s nominees are confirmed.

Confirming Gaiser and Trump’s other nominees is Thune’s most urgent job as majority leader. If he lets Republican holdouts run out the clock, he will have helped squander lifetime appointments with no one to blame but himself.


0
Access Commentsx
()
x