In a much-predicted outcome, a federal judge has forbidden California from enforcing a series of state laws intended to restrict and control the on-duty behavior of federal agents.
The laws prevented ICE agents (who have been harassed and threatened at their homes) from covering their faces while performing law enforcement duties and required them to wear identification with their names and badge numbers. The author of the failed state law on masking by federal agents, the state senator and congressman-elect Scott Wiener, celebrated the passage of his meaningless bill last year as “huge news.”
It wasn’t. The Supremacy Clause of the Constitution establishes valid federal law as “the supreme Law of the Land,” while Article I assigns authority over immigration and naturalization to Congress. ICE never worked for the California legislature.
You can read the short “order entering permanent injunction” from District Court Judge Christina Snyder, a Bill Clinton appointee who is now on senior status, here.
The injunction is permanent and sweeping, entirely forbidding state and local officials to enforce state laws regulating masking and required identification against federal agents:

The district court order followed an earlier ruling with similar reasoning from the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals.
California Attorney General Rob Bonta boasted earlier this year about a temporary and later-reversed court victory that appeared to accept the validity of the state laws.
Like other state officials, Bonta has now gone curiously silent on the matter following the court’s permanent injunction.
In a DOJ press release, Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward, Jr. said that the permanent injunction “confirms a basic constitutional principle: states do not have the authority to regulate the Federal Government or dictate how federal law enforcement officers perform their official duties.”
“The Constitution does not permit states to interfere with federal operations or place federal officers and their families at risk,” Woodward added. “This injunction ensures that federal law enforcement officers can continue carrying out their important missions without unlawful state interference.”
Eight states, including California, have passed unenforceable laws forbidding federal agents from wearing face masks while on duty.







